April 10, 2026

The Oral Argument Toolkit

thread-viewer

When I was preparing for my first appellate oral argument, I printed out the entire record on appeal—some 2,000-plus pages—and carted the unwieldy thing to the hearing. It was a rookie mistake. While I looked primed and prepared for a trial, the fact was, this wasn’t a trial. Needless to say, I never opened the box during the argument. Since then, I’ve refined my approach to oral argument preparation and left the carts and boxes behind. Now, my oral argument preparation centers around what I call the oral argument toolkit: two binders that contain only the essential documents and information that are needed for the hearing.

The toolkit serves two primary functions. First, creating the toolkit is preparation for the oral argument, and the process of crafting the toolkit carries equal weight to the toolkit’s substance. Oral arguments are often scheduled several months after briefs have been submitted. This lapse necessitates revisiting the legal issues and reacquainting oneself with the case’s finer details and evidentiary record. Assembling the toolkit demands a meticulous reexamination of the record, briefs, and the case’s complex legal issues. Thoroughly retracing these steps by creating the toolkit ensures optimal preparation for the upcoming oral argument.

Second, the toolkit serves as a practical resource in the days leading up to and at the hearing. The toolkit streamlines the process of navigating complex appellate records by distilling voluminous materials into a compilation of essential briefs, pleadings, and record evidence. By centralizing your preparation within this toolkit, you can swiftly access and analyze pertinent information without wading through a dense record.

So whether you are preparing for your first or your fiftieth appellate oral argument, consider creating an oral argument toolkit. My approach is to divide the toolkit into two binders: first, the oral argument binder; and second, the briefs and major documents binder.

The Oral Argument Binder

The oral argument binder contains the critical materials you’ll reference at the podium during the hearing itself. Carefully curate this binder to include:

Oral Argument Script and Outline. This item may be controversial to some. Many practice guides and articles on oral argument caution against creating a script.[1] The fear is that the oralist will read directly from the script during oral argument, thus turning what should be a free-flowing question-and-answer session between the advocate and the panel into a stale, rigid lecture. My preparation involves writing out the script, and then condensing that script down to an outline of the main points that I want to make and the order I want to make them.[2] If you are concerned about overreliance on the script, then forego this item and skip straight to the outline. And, as always, do not read from the script or the outline at the hearing.[3]

Question-and-Answer Table. Prepare for the inevitable back-and-forth by creating a two-column table. List potential questions from the panel in one column, organized by topic area. In the second column, provide corresponding bullet-point answers drawing from the evidence, record materials, and legal arguments raised in your briefing.

Challenging Issues and Responses. No case is as open-and-shut as you would hope it to be. Many times, you may think: “I hope the judge don’t ask about X or Y.” As tricky as these questions may be, it is essential that you tackle these thorny issues directly. Having thoughtful responses at the ready for these “hard” questions prevents being caught off guard during questioning.

Caselaw Table. Be prepared to discuss the major cases relied on by the parties in the briefs. Summarize the critical facts, procedural posture, holdings, and rationales of the major precedents cited in the briefs. A concise table allows you to quickly reference how these key cases do or don’t apply to the circumstances before the court.

Statutory and Regulatory Provisions. If statutory language, regulations, or other codified authorities are central to the disputed issues, extract and compile the relevant provisions verbatim into your binder to easily reference during the argument. For example, if a key issue on appeal is whether the trial court erred in admitting or excluding certain evidence on a motion for summary judgment, it is advisable to have the text of La. Code Civ. Proc. art. 966 (or at least the portion of Article 966 pertaining to admissible summary-judgment evidence) at hand.

Record Citations List. Before the briefing stage, you should have reviewed the entire record on appeal. During your review, keep track of any important record citations by creating a list with descriptions and pincites for the record’s most pivotal materials.

Critical Record Excerpts. Gather pivotal record excerpts—whether a contract clause, statutory provision, or key trial testimony—into a single document. This dedicated compilation ensures easy access to critical evidence throughout the hearing.

The Briefs and Major Documents Binder

The briefs and major documents binder should contain all of the key written advocacy and record materials related to the appeal, but which you won’t need directly at the podium. It provides a convenient repository for all of the most important case materials in one place. Specifically, this binder should include:

  • All briefs filed by the parties (opening, response, and reply briefs)
  • Any substantive motions filed in the appellate court (e.g., motion to dismiss, motion to strike, exceptions raised on appeal, etc.)
  • The judgment being appealed from the lower court
  • Any written reasons by the lower court explaining the judgment
  • Key pleadings from the lower court that are central to the issues on appeal (e.g., petition, motion for summary judgment, exception, etc.)
  • Any critical exhibits or evidence from the record

While this supplementary binder will likely remain untouched during the actual oral argument, having the briefs and key record materials consolidated in one place allows for efficient preparation and fact-checking ahead of the hearing.

Conclusion

The oral argument toolkit enables you to step confidently to the lectern, having thoroughly retraced your steps through the record and arguments. With key materials organized for easy reference, you can maintain full command of the issues while focusing your delivery on persuasively engaging the court’s questions. Leverage these tools properly, and you’ll be well-equipped to advocate effectively at oral argument.

Originally published in The Baton Rouge Lawyer, a publication of the Baton Rouge Bar Association.

[1] See, e.g., Stephen J. Dwyer, et al., Effective Oral Argument: Six Pitches, Five Do’s, and Five Don’ts from One Judge and Two Lawyers, 33 Stetson L. Rev. 347, 356–67 (2010).

[2] Id. at 357.

[3] See Unif. R. La. Cts. App. r. 2-15.3 (prohibiting counsel from reading from briefs).