February 6, 2026
When Louisiana Appeals Require a Five-Judge Panel
The typical appellate panel consists of three judges. But did you know that there are instances where a five-judge panel is required? Under La. Const. art. V, § 8(B), when a three-judge panel decides to modify or reverse a judgment of a district court or an administrative agency determination in a workers’ compensation claim but one judge dissents, then the case must be reargued before a panel of at least five judges. A majority of the judges on the new, five-judge panel must concur to render a judgment. This rule only applies in civil matters.
What happens if the court of appeal fails to refer the appeal to a five-judge panel? That’s reversible error, and you need to seek rehearing or writs from the Louisiana Supreme Court.
See Thompson v. La. State Univ. Health Sci. Ctr.-Shreveport, 25-01388, p. 1 (La. 1/21/26), ___ So. 3d ____, 2026 WL 160566, at *1 (citing La. Const. art. V, § 8(B); Bank of New Orleans & Tr. Co. v. Seavey, 383 So. 2d 354, 357 (La. 1980)).